Roofing referrals for Seattle & nearby townsCall: (206) 984-7830
(206) 984-7830

Shingles, metal or cedar: roofing for the Northwest

roofingseattle.net

A roof in the Seattle area spends months wet, shaded and shaken by wind, so the best material depends on more than price. This guide compares the common choices and lists what published cost sources say about each.

Need roofing help now?
Call now to be connected with a local roofing contractor in Seattle.
(206) 984-7830

A roof in the Seattle area spends months wet, shaded and shaken by wind, so the best material depends on more than price. This guide compares the common choices and lists what published cost sources say about each.

What the climate asks of a roof

The National Weather Service describes Sea-Tac annual precipitation as roughly 37 to 38 inches, with a rainy season from October through March and more than 75 percent of the year's precipitation falling in that winter wet season. A roof here is rarely dry from fall to spring. Add dry summers that bake the surface, windstorms that test every edge, an occasional wet snow, and heavy tree cover in many neighborhoods, and the real questions are how a material handles constant moisture, shade and debris, and how well the installer handles flashing and drainage.

Moss is part of that picture. Oregon State Extension says it thrives in the wet Pacific Northwest climate but also needs shade, and that it traps debris, holds moisture and can lift asphalt shingles so water gets underneath. Our guide to moss on Seattle roofs goes deeper. Any material in a shady lot needs a maintenance plan, and the material only changes how much trouble moss can cause.

Prices at a glance

Every number below comes from a published cost page, and each page measures its own thing. Angi's Seattle figures and RoofingCalc's greater Seattle figures are regional; HomeGuide's cedar, TPO and torch-down figures are national. Treat them as ranges to compare with real bids, not quotes.

MaterialInstalled cost per sq ftSource and scope
Asphalt shingle$3 to $11 (Angi); $6.50 to $10.50 (RoofingCalc)Seattle; greater Seattle
Metal roofing$5 to $22 (Angi); $12.50 to $20.50 (RoofingCalc)Seattle; greater Seattle
Standing seam metal$7 to $30 (Angi)Seattle
Wood shingle$6 to $18 (Angi)Seattle
Cedar shakes$12.50 to $18.50 (RoofingCalc); $7 to $15 (HomeGuide)Greater Seattle; national
TPO$4 to $10 (HomeGuide)National
Torch-down$3.50 to $7 (HomeGuide)National

For whole jobs, Angi gives a typical Seattle roof replacement range of $8,045 to $17,399 and a typical total for a metal roof of $8,207 to $23,075. Those totals assume different house sizes and scopes, so use our Seattle roof cost guide to see how removal and decking repair add to the total.

Asphalt shingles

Architectural asphalt shingles are the most common roof on mid-century ramblers and the large subdivisions across King, Snohomish and Pierce counties. They are familiar to every roofer, repairs are straightforward, and they cost less than most other options in the sources above. Their weak points here are the same as anywhere wet: moss growth on north slopes and under trees, granule loss, and sealant strips that wind can break. If you are comparing brands, ask about the manufacturer's written warranty terms and who stands behind installation, because they are separate things. See asphalt shingle roofing for how a job usually goes.

Standing-seam and other metal roofing

Metal sheds rain and debris quickly and gives moss less to hold, which is a point in its favor under conifers. It also costs more, and the spread in the sources is wide because panel type, gauge, finish and roof complexity all change the price. Standing seam, with raised interlocking seams and concealed fasteners, sits at the top of the cost range. Metal can be loud in heavy rain without solid decking and underlayment, so ask about that. Installation detail matters more than the panel itself: valleys, penetrations and edges are where leaks start. Browse metal roofing in Seattle if you are leaning this way.

Cedar shakes and shingles

Cedar has a long history on Northwest craftsman and waterfront homes and gives a look that other materials copy poorly. It also asks for more care. Wood in a wet, shaded setting can hold moisture, and a cedar roof benefits from good ventilation, regular cleaning of debris, and attention to moss. Some neighborhoods and HOAs have rules about roofing material and appearance, so check before you commit; our guide on HOA and condo roof replacement explains who decides. Local fire and building rules can also affect wood roofing, so ask the permit office, and see cedar shake roofing for the service overview.

Flat and low-slope roofs

Flat roofs are not truly flat; they are low-slope and rely on membranes. Torch-down uses heat-welded modified bitumen sheets, TPO is a single-ply white membrane with heat-welded seams, and coatings can extend the life of a sound membrane. HomeGuide lists installed TPO at $4 to $10 per square foot and torch-down at $3.50 to $7, both national, while RoofingCalc lists a PVC membrane at $8.50 to $14.50 for King County replacement. Bothell, for one, states that torch-down or hot-tar roofing needs a separate fire permit, so ask about that early. Our flat roof options guide compares the three, and the service pages cover torch-down roofing and TPO roofing.

What matters beyond the surface

  • Underlayment and flashing. The surface sheds most water; the underlayment, valley metal and flashing handle the rest. Ask what will be used and where.
  • Ventilation. A wet climate makes attic airflow important for any material. See roof ventilation and the guide on attic condensation.
  • Weight and structure. Heavier coverings can change what a permit office requires. Several cities set weight thresholds in pounds per square foot; see our roofing permit guide.
  • Tear-off versus overlay. Seattle's residential code does not allow re-covering where a roof already has two or more applications of any roof covering or where it is water-soaked or deteriorated. Ask which applies to you.
  • Energy code. Bellevue states that on a residential roof replacement with an exposed cavity, insulation must be installed to full depth, so a material change can bring insulation costs.

Installation season and weather

Most roofing is done in the drier months, and that is when good roofers book up. Replacement in the wet season is possible, but sheathing and underlayment should not sit exposed in rain, so ask how the crew protects an open roof if the forecast turns. Torch-down and some adhesives and sealants also behave differently in cold, damp conditions, and shingle sealant strips seat more slowly when temperatures drop. None of this rules out a winter job; it means the bid should say what happens on a wet day and who pays to protect the house.

Life after installation

Every material in this guide does better with simple upkeep. Keep gutters and valleys clear of needles and leaves, trim branches that overhang the roof or scrape it in wind, and have a roofer check flashing after a hard storm. Roof cleaning for moss is a separate service; HomeGuide lists national cleaning prices of $0.15 to $0.60 per square foot. Oregon State Extension says improper pressure washing can damage shingles, so leave that to a professional and do not do it yourself. A roof maintenance visit costs less than a leak.

Choosing for your house

Match the material to the house, the lot and your plans. A shaded craftsman with a complex roof line and a budget limit often ends up with architectural shingles and a moss plan. A longer stay and a roof under tall firs make metal worth pricing. A cedar roof makes sense where the style, HOA rules and your willingness to maintain it line up. A low-slope addition needs a membrane no matter what the main roof is. Ask for at least two written bids on the same material so you can compare scope, and ask each roofer to explain the underlayment, flashing and cleanup. Our guide to hiring a roofer lists the questions.

Call now to be connected with a local roofing contractor in Seattle.
(206) 984-7830

Frequently asked questions

Which roofing material costs the least in the Seattle area?
In the cost sources used here, asphalt shingle has the lowest installed range, with Angi listing $3 to $11 per square foot in Seattle. Torch-down is lower in HomeGuide's national figures, but it is a low-slope material and not a substitute on a pitched roof.
Is metal roofing good for moss?
Metal gives moss less to hold than shingles, but moss and debris can still collect in shaded areas and at laps and valleys. Trimming trees for sunlight is the most effective long-term fix, according to Oregon State Extension.
Can I switch materials when I reroof?
Often, but a change in weight or material type can matter to the permit office and to any HOA. Ask both before you sign.
Do cedar roofs work in Seattle's wet climate?
They are common on Northwest homes and can work, but they need more upkeep than asphalt in shade and rain. Ask roofers about ventilation, underlayment and cleaning.
Call now to be connected with a local roofing contractor in Seattle.
(206) 984-7830

Last updated:

☎ Call (206) 984-7830